Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Time Is A Ghost's avatar

This was beautiful. I loved how the story transformed what first seemed like a curse into a relationship with the living world. The reveal that Rootvein wasn’t a disease but a symbiosis completely reframed everything that came before it.

“The roots really do remember.” That line hit me the hardest. It felt like the entire heart of the story.

Your worldbuilding is extraordinary, but what stays with me most is Xanthe finally realizing she was never broken only misunderstood. What a wonderful speculative fairytale. 🌿🖤

Elephants in Space's avatar

This is pretty good. The descriptions and characterizations build good depth, and you leave plenty of room for the reader to imagine around the corner. I also want to call out how well you balanced the stakes, which is something I think even well established writers get wrong kind of a lot. The world you describe has rules which we immediately pick up on: the imaginable bigotry or a small society, giant moths and extinct chickens, exotic traders with interesting wares. The fact that she goes out on her quest out of curiosity and not because of some emergency or immediate necessity lets the growth center on her entirely, without having to worry about responsibility to the plot.

Because this was a quiet task though, the reader never has to wait for it to start or get good. With higher stakes, the story would hinge on "Did she win?" But as it is, if you had stopped at the medical facility with her going home after learning about herself: good story. If she had pressed on, found the botanical lab alone, scooped up the flowers, and gone home: good story. If she meets Tiresias and he says they're all leaving forever, but now she knows they exists: still... good story. All of it together though means she gets a quest, faces challenges, expands her world, achieves her goal, and gives us a idea of what she'll do next.

While connecting with the audience. In 3500 words.

So, pretty good.

Have you read much by Terry Brooks? The way you blend genres and build the world out of personal perspective reminds me of his writing.

35 more comments...

No posts

Ready for more?